This Article  • Full text  • PDF  • Correction  • Reply to article  • Send to a friend  • Save in My Folder  • Save to citation manager  • Permissions  Citing Articles  • Citation map  • Citing articles on HighWire  • Citing articles on Web of Science (102)  • Contact me when this article is cited  Related Content  • Related letters  • Similar articles in this journal  Topic Collections  • Psychiatry  • Psychotherapy  • Psychiatry, Other  • Randomized Controlled Trial  • Prognosis/ Outcomes  • Alert me on articles by topic  Social Bookmarking   What's this?

Randomized Trial of Schema-Focused Therapy vs Transference-Focused Psychotherapy

Josephine Giesen-Bloo, MSc; Richard van Dyck, MD, PhD; Philip Spinhoven, PhD; Willem van Tilburg, MD, PhD; Carmen Dirksen, PhD; Thea van Asselt, MSc; Ismay Kremers, PhD; Marjon Nadort, MSc; Arnoud Arntz, PhD

Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2006;63:649-658.

Context  Borderline personality disorder is a severe and chronic psychiatric condition, prevalent throughout health care settings. Only limited effects of current treatments have been documented.

Objective  To compare the effectiveness of schema-focused therapy (SFT) and psychodynamically based transference-focused psychotherapy (TFP) in patients with borderline personality disorder.

Design  A multicenter, randomized, 2-group design.

Setting  Four general community mental health centers.

Participants  Eighty-eight patients with a Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index, fourth version, score greater than a predetermined cutoff score.

Intervention  Three years of either SFT or TFP with sessions twice a week.

Main Outcome Measures  Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index, fourth version, score; quality of life; general psychopathologic dysfunction; and measures of SFT/TFP personality concepts. Patient assessments were made before randomization and then every 3 months for 3 years.

Results  Data on 44 SFT patients and 42 TFP patients were available. The sociodemographic and clinical characteristics of the groups were similar at baseline. Survival analyses revealed a higher dropout risk for TFP patients than for SFT patients (P = .01). Using an intention-to-treat approach, statistically and clinically significant improvements were found for both treatments on all measures after 1-, 2-, and 3-year treatment periods. After 3 years of treatment, survival analyses demonstrated that significantly more SFT patients recovered (relative risk = 2.18; P = .04) or showed reliable clinical improvement (relative risk = 2.33; P = .009) on the Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index, fourth version. Robust analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) showed that they also improved more in general psychopathologic dysfunction and measures of SFT/TFP personality concepts (P<.001). Finally, SFT patients showed greater increases in quality of life than TFP patients (robust ANCOVAs, P=.03 and P<.001).

Conclusions  Three years of SFT or TFP proved to be effective in reducing borderline personality disorder–specific and general psychopathologic dysfunction and measures of SFT/TFP concepts and in improving quality of life; SFT is more effective than TFP for all measures.

Author Affiliations: Department of Medical Psychology (Ms Giesen-Bloo) and Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Medical Technology Assessment (Dr Dirksen and Ms van Asselt), Academic Hospital Maastricht, Maastricht; Department of Medical, Clinical, and Experimental Psychology, University Maastricht, Maastricht (Ms Giesen-Bloo and Dr Arntz); Department of Psychiatry, Vrije Universiteit University Medical Center/Geestelijke Gezondheidszorg Buitenamstel, Amsterdam (Drs van Dyck and van Tilburg and Ms Nadort); and Department of Clinical and Health Psychology, Leiden University, Leiden (Drs Spinhoven and Kremers), the Netherlands.

CiteULike    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    Twitter     What's this?

RELATED LETTERS

Hope for Sustaining a Positive 3-Year Therapeutic Relationship With Patients With Borderline Personality Disorder
Brin F. S. Grenyer
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2007;64(5):609.
EXTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Knowledge of the Effectiveness of Treatments for Borderline Personality Disorder Is Not Yet Sufficient to Justify the Lack of a Control Condition
Steve Pearce
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2007;64(5):609.
EXTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Questions Concerning the Randomized Trial of Schema-Focused Therapy vs Transference-Focused Psychotherapy
Frank Yeomans
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2007;64(5):609-610.
EXTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Questions Concerning the Randomized Trial of Schema-Focused Therapy vs Transference-Focused Psychotherapy—Reply
Josephine Giesen-Bloo and Arnoud Arntz
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2007;64(5):610-611.
EXTRACT | FULL TEXT  

THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CITED BY OTHER ARTICLES

The Interpersonal Dimension of Borderline Personality Disorder: Toward a Neuropeptide Model
Stanley and Siever
Am. J. Psychiatry 2010;167:24-39.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Community mental healthcare for people with severe personality disorder: narrative review
Koekkoek et al.
The Psychiatrist 2010;34:24-30.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

A Randomized Trial of Dialectical Behavior Therapy Versus General Psychiatric Management for Borderline Personality Disorder
McMain et al.
Am. J. Psychiatry 2009;166:1365-1374.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Randomized Controlled Trial of Outpatient Mentalization-Based Treatment Versus Structured Clinical Management for Borderline Personality Disorder
Bateman and Fonagy
Am. J. Psychiatry 2009;166:1355-1364.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Insight, Transference Interpretation, and Therapeutic Change in the Dynamic Psychotherapy of Borderline Personality Disorder
Gabbard and Horowitz
Am. J. Psychiatry 2009;166:517-521.
FULL TEXT  

Analyzing Effectiveness of Long-term Psychodynamic Psychotherapy
Beck and Bhar
JAMA 2009;301:931-931.
FULL TEXT  

Analyzing Effectiveness of Long-term Psychodynamic Psychotherapy
Roepke and Renneberg
JAMA 2009;301:931-932.
FULL TEXT  

Early intervention for adolescents with borderline personality disorder using cognitive analytic therapy: randomised controlled trial
Chanen et al.
Br. J. Psychiatry 2008;193:477-484.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Effectiveness of Long-term Psychodynamic Psychotherapy: A Meta-analysis
Leichsenring and Rabung
JAMA 2008;300:1551-1565.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Psychological therapies provision: views from primary care
Ward et al.
The Psychiatrist 2008;32:369-374.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Transference Interpretations in Dynamic Psychotherapy: Do They Really Yield Sustained Effects?
Hoglend et al.
Am. J. Psychiatry 2008;165:763-771.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Out-patient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: cost-effectiveness of schema-focused therapy v. transference-focused psychotherapy
van Asselt et al.
Br. J. Psychiatry 2008;192:450-457.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Psychotherapies and Lasting Change
Levy
Am. J. Psychiatry 2008;165:556-559.
FULL TEXT  

8-Year Follow-Up of Patients Treated for Borderline Personality Disorder: Mentalization-Based Treatment Versus Treatment as Usual
Bateman and Fonagy
Am. J. Psychiatry 2008;165:631-638.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Proposals for massive expansion of psychological therapies would be counterproductive across society
Summerfield and Veale
Br. J. Psychiatry 2008;192:326-330.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Augmenting Psychotherapy for Borderline Personality Disorder: The STEPPS Program
Silk
Am. J. Psychiatry 2008;165:413-415.
FULL TEXT  

Systems Training for Emotional Predictability and Problem Solving (STEPPS) for Outpatients With Borderline Personality Disorder: A Randomized Controlled Trial and 1-Year Follow-Up
Blum et al.
Am. J. Psychiatry 2008;165:468-478.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Cognitive-behavioural intervention for self-harm: randomised controlled trial
Slee et al.
Br. J. Psychiatry 2008;192:202-211.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Policy on the prevention of suicidal behaviour; one treatment for all may be an unrealistic expectation
Pitman
JRSM 2007;100:461-464.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Do All Roads Lead to Rome? New Findings on Borderline Personality Disorder
Gabbard
Am. J. Psychiatry 2007;164:853-855.
FULL TEXT  

Hope for Sustaining a Positive 3-Year Therapeutic Relationship With Patients With Borderline Personality Disorder
Grenyer
Arch Gen Psychiatry 2007;64:609-609.
FULL TEXT  

Questions Concerning the Randomized Trial of Schema-Focused Therapy vs Transference-Focused Psychotherapy--Reply
Giesen-Bloo and Arntz
Arch Gen Psychiatry 2007;64:610-611.
FULL TEXT  

Knowledge of the Effectiveness of Treatments for Borderline Personality Disorder Is Not Yet Sufficient to Justify the Lack of a Control Condition
Pearce
Arch Gen Psychiatry 2007;64:609-609.
FULL TEXT  

Questions Concerning the Randomized Trial of Schema-Focused Therapy vs Transference-Focused Psychotherapy
Yeomans
Arch Gen Psychiatry 2007;64:609-610.
FULL TEXT  

Two New Psychotherapies for Borderline Personality Disorder
JWatch Psychiatry 2006;2006:1-1.
FULL TEXT